Were any French aluminum bike builders, as Rene Herse was, coming from an aircraft fabrication background?
David Feldman
Vancouver, WA
>
> Greetings All,
>
> An almost perpetual thread in vintage cycling circles is the subject of
weight. After all, what constitutes a "lightweight" cycle is the fact that
it was constructed of lightweight tubing, with a conscious effort by the
builder to minimize weight while maximizing performance - not an easy
balancing act, and more often robbing Peter to pay Paul.
>
> I have always been fascinated by the French obsession with this subject,
and the ability of French builders to think outside of the box, utilizing
alternative materials and designs to achieve this end. It was the French who
pioneered virtually every exotic, lightweight material from aluminum to
carbon fiber in their designs.
>
> Two pioneers in the development of ultra-lightweight cycles were Pierre
Caminade and Nicola Barra. Not much has been written about either of these
great builders. I'll put Barra aside for a later subject, but here are a few
notes on Pierre Caminade, along with published excerpts. Perhaps some of you
saw my 1936 Caminargent (by Caminade) at Lars Anderson, where I presented a
short discourse. The bike, model Bordeaux-Paris, weighs just 12.5 pounds,
and to date, is still the lightest commercially produced cycle of record
(weather or not the statistics on this are accurate or not is open to
debate, but please accept the fact that 12.5 pounds, fully outfitted, is
darned light).
>
> Pierre Caminade was born near Bordeaux, south west France in the late
1879. He set up shop as a framebuilder in Bios-Colombes, an inner suburb of
Paris around 1910, just before WW1, and quickly gained reputation for
producing lightweight racing cycles to the Buffalo (Paris) Velodrome
contingent of racers. His works at this time were exclusively of lightweight
steel tubing, track-specific. After WW1, the use of aluminum, having tested
with great successes in aircraft and artillery uses, assimilated into
mainstream use. According to cycling historian Raymond Henry, the idea of
aluminum racing cycles was not new, with Rupalley building a successful
prototype in 1896 of gas-welded, lugless design, and the firm of Delage
developing a short production run of lightweight, lugged and bolted aluminum
frames in 1933.
>
> But it was Caminade who successfully built a comprehensive lightweight
cycle and put it into production for a period that was to last over 20
years, starting in 1936. Promoted by the Societe du Duralumin ( a French
trade council headquartered in Paris), the "Caminargent" cycle was launched.
Available in two models, the "Bordeaux-Paris" and "Randonneuse", both frames
were identical in design and execution, consisting of octogonal section,
double-butted (on inner walls) Duralumin tubes with cork-filled dampening
ends. The tubes were joined using very high tolerance cast aluminum lugs
(quite ornate with Art Nouveau details). The lugs were fitted with opposing
setscrews that allowed the main tubes to be compress-fitted and adjusted for
alignment. The screws were detailed with the Caminade shield logo.
Round-oval section fork blades and stays are fitted with cast fork ends,
plug-in type with setscrew fasteners - a predecessor by more than half a
century to the replaceable rear fork ends of todays state of the art racing
cycles.The headtube is a single cast piece, integrating headtube and
headlugs into one contiguous casting (ala later A. Singer).
>
> The cycles were fitted with Caminade handlebar and stem, Caminade extruded
rims, Caminade (Atom) hubs, Caminade saddle (aluminum railed predecessor to
the Ideale Duralumin railed saddle) Stronglight 49D crankset, Duralumin
(Lyotard) pedals.
>
> The Randonneuse model was fitted with 3-speed Caminade derailleur, called
"Le Rectiligne", which Pierre Caminade developed in 1933. Modeled after the
1904 Terrot Model H hub, Le Rectigline was a true "freewheel" in that gears
were changed NOT by shifting a chain over a static cluster of gears, but by
moving the gear cluster in and out while maintaining constant, straight
chain line. Used with a double chain wheel, Caminade named his gear "Le 6
Vitesses Caminade" (6 speeds) for cyclotourists.
>
> Below is an excerpt from August 12, 1936 issue of _Cycling_:
>
> "New 13 pound French Road Racing Cycle
>
> A new duralumin machine has just been produced under the name of the
"Caminargent", which presents certain constructional features of interest.
>
> The Caminargent is built up entirely with bolted lugs, no welding being
employed anywhere. The tubes are octogonal in section and the bolting
arrangements are carefully designed to avoid any possible weakening of the
tubes, whilst the last mentioned are cork-filled at their extremities to
absorb vibration, as duralumin alloys are, in their present stage of
development, sometimes liable to rather rapid fatigue and molecular
disintegration.
>
> The steel employed in ordinary good class cycle tubing is tested for a
shearing strain of 60 kg per sq. cm., whilst the duralumin used in the
"Caminargent" will only support 42 kg. Whilst the resistance is thus less,
the density of the light metal is only 2.7, as compared with 7.8 for steel.
It is thus possible to double the section when employing aluminum, and as a
result we have a tube with a much higher resistance - 84 kg per sq. cm.,
with a weight reduction of 30 percent (K.D. - sound familiar, Cannondale and
Klein?).
>
> The construction of the front fork head (K.D. fork crown) is interesting.
The lower end of the steel tube (steerer) is pierced with a number of holes
and the aluminum lug taking the forks is cast into this (KD. in other words,
the steel steerer is cast into the aluminum fork crown integrally). The
metal running into the holes forms a very solid joint. The forks themselves
are in duralumin, like the rest of the machine, including handlebars and
seat pillar. No plating is needed and the machine is simply polished. The
weight, all on, is 6 kg for the road-racing (Bordeaux-Paris) model, and 8.9
kg for the roadster (Randonneuse). "
>
> >>My riding impressions of this cycle are very positive. Yes, it is quite
whippy, especially going up hills, but once you get into the groove and
fully synergize with tis cycle, the ride is quite enjoyable. I know of only
one other Caminargent in the US, and very few have survived world-wide. With
that in mind, rarity dictates that putting this machine through all of its
motions, on a true technical road test, would risk extinction of this great
marque.
>
> Hope you enjoyed this mini discourse on Caminade.
>
> Ken Denny
>
> Boston, MA
>
> 34 degrees and I'm riding a 24 pound, 1948 Sun Manx tt today - talk about
contrasts!
>
>
>
>
>
> ---------------------------------
> Do you Yahoo!?
> Yahoo! Tax Center - forms, calculators, tips, and more