This is an interesting topic. I don't know how it started but it sure has generated some lively debate. I dig a beautifully executed lugged frame as much as you all, and I hope to try my hand at it soon. Dale eloquently provided his opinion, which I can relate to, and I can understand most others' as well, HOWEVER, (and pardon my lack of eloquence) bicycles are for riding, and I think that whatever gets someone out on a bicycle is a good thing. TIG, lugs, carbon, aluminum.....whatever. I remember being a campy and eyetalian snob until I learned how to make bikes (by the TIG method). I don't necessarily like all methods, but I can appreciate them for what there are because they get people RIDING. I have been car-less for two years now and my attitude about THE BICYCLE has undergone a profound change. It's not just a hobby anymore. It's my life. I may be flamed for this, but get your asses out there and ride.
Jay Sexton
Sebastopol, CA