Thought I would try a complete change and express my opinion on the subject of mudguards/fenders. It all arose again only this week when completing a restoration of Claud Butler "Classique" and the client's wish not to have these parts put on the finished job. I realise this is a matter of personal choice but for the life of me I can't see the point in anyone going without this vital accessory. I accept anyone riding competitively would be without them for the obvious reasons , but not having them affixed for pleasure or domestic riding to me does'nt make sense. For one thing a bike does'nt look right without them as they give the machine a good finished look. To ride without mudguards can shorten the life of the bike frame and accessories causing paintwork chipping to seat tube and chainstays, suface water into bearings and rear and front mechs whilst the poor old saddle is taking the brunt of the damage.I have always favoured mudguards not only for their appearance but for the purpose they were made for , being part of the bicycle.
Members will no doubt have their veiws on whether or not mudguards/fenders are a necessary part of bicycle they own, purchase, build up, or ride, Is the choice going to be they are not needed under any circumstances! Hope not!!
I wonder
Doug Smith
North Dorset
UK