Re: [CR]Bayliss Wiley, BSA and Cyclo Freewheel Unit Hubs

(Example: Framebuilders:Bernard Carré)

Date: Sat, 31 Dec 2005 15:54:26 -0500
From: <joebz@optonline.net>
Subject: Re: [CR]Bayliss Wiley, BSA and Cyclo Freewheel Unit Hubs
In-reply-to: <BAY115-F3032C44AAB4331FB7785AABF2B0@phx.gbl>
To: neil foddering <neilfoddering@hotmail.com>
References:
cc: classicrendezvous@bikelist.org

The second BW patent is likely GB514931, which relates to a spindle (or axle) and the double sided bearing for such hub.

Joe Bender-Zanoni
Great Notch, NJ


----- Original Message -----
From: neil foddering
Date: Sat, 31 Dec 2005 10:31:00 -0000
Subject: [CR]Bayliss Wiley, BSA and Cyclo Freewheel Unit Hubs


> I have two Bayliss Wiley Unit hubs: the early low flange version,

\r?\n> and a NOS

\r?\n> post-war large flange model. I also have a Cyclo "Tank" Unit hub.

\r?\n> Please

\r?\n> see the photo on:

\r?\n>

\r?\n> http://photobucket.com/albums/v396/hadendowa/Unit%20Freewheel%20Hubs/?sc=1

\r?\n>

\r?\n> and in the following sub-albums accessible from that page: "BW LF

\r?\n> UNIT HUB",

\r?\n> "BW SF UNIT HUB" and "CYCLO UNIT HUB"

\r?\n>

\r?\n> The Bayliss Wiley Unit Hub patent (number GB461951) was published

\r?\n> on 26th

\r?\n> February, 1937. For full patent details, including drawings, see:

\r?\n>

\r?\n> http://v3.espacenet.com/textdoc?DB=EPODOC&IDX=GB461951&F=0

\r?\n>

\r?\n> The BW small flange Unit hub is marked with this patent. The later

\r?\n> large

\r?\n> flange BW Unit hub in the photos is marked "Patent Applied For",

\r?\n> but I have

\r?\n> been unable to find any patent having been granted for this model,

\r?\n> and I

\r?\n> don't know what the specific patent claims were If you compare

\r?\n> the photos

\r?\n> of the large and small flange BW hubs, you will see a marked

\r?\n> difference in

\r?\n> the size of the bearing housings, but what the actu8al changes

\r?\n> were, I don't

\r?\n> know - I haven't stripped any of the hubs (which is probably why

\r?\n> they're

\r?\n> still working).

\r?\n>

\r?\n> The Cyclo Unit hub is marked in French with the Cyclo logo and

\r?\n> "BREVETE

\r?\n> SGDG" on the barrel, and the Cyclo logo and "SGDG" and "TANK

\r?\n> BREVETE" on the

\r?\n> adjustable bearing cone. I bought this on eBay from France, hence

\r?\n> the

\r?\n> French markings, but it has 40 spoke holes (as do the BW hubs)

\r?\n> which I

\r?\n> understand to be unusual for the French market, 36 holes being much

\r?\n> more

\r?\n> common. (My hub does not have the eyeletted spoke holes on the

\r?\n> freewheel

\r?\n> side flange which are specified in the 1939 Cyclo catalogue).

\r?\n>

\r?\n> Perhaps they were made in England and exported to France via French

\r?\n> Cyclo,

\r?\n> and stamped accordingly? The reason I believe that this might be

\r?\n> the case

\r?\n> is that the 1939 catalogue states that these hubs were "Made under

\r?\n> BSA

\r?\n> license (sic), Patent No. 498931". For details of this patent,

\r?\n> which was

\r?\n> published on 17th January 1939, see:

\r?\n>

\r?\n> http://v3.espacenet.com/textdoc?DB=EPODOC&IDX=GB498931&F=0&QPN=GB498931

\r?\n>

\r?\n> My hub appears externally similar to the hub in the BSA patent

\r?\n> drawings,

\r?\n> although it only steps down once from the flange to the barrel,

\r?\n> unlike the

\r?\n> hub in the patent drawings and the exploded diagram in the 1939

\r?\n> Ccyclo

\r?\n> catalogue (and, come to that, the BW hubs). However, if it IS the

\r?\n> BSA

\r?\n> patent hub, then I think it more likely, particularly in view of

\r?\n> the

\r?\n> 40-hole spoking, that was British made, and exported. It doesn't

\r?\n> seem

\r?\n> likely to me that both British and French Cyclo factories would go

\r?\n> to the

\r?\n> expense of tooling up to make the same pattern of hub.

\r?\n>

\r?\n> However, this is all conjecture on my part - it's just as possible

\r?\n> that it

\r?\n> was made in France, and distributed in the UK by British Cyclo.

\r?\n>

\r?\n> It is a "flip flop" (fixed/free) hub, and the BW Unit hub was also

\r?\n> available

\r?\n> fixed/free - it is listed in the 1939 Brown Bothers catalogue as

\r?\n> being

\r?\n> available in 4 configurations:

\r?\n>

\r?\n> Single freewheel

\r?\n> Single freewheel/fixed

\r?\n> Three speed

\r?\n> Three speed/ fixed

\r?\n>

\r?\n> The only options listed in the 1950 Cyclo catalogue relate to 3, 4

\r?\n> or 5

\r?\n> speed, and by this time, it appears that Cyclo had dropped the BSA-

\r?\n> licensed

\r?\n> model, and were using the Bayliss Wiley Unit hub - if you refer to

\r?\n> the 1950

\r?\n> catalogue page, you will see it listed as "B.W. FREEWHEEL HUB

\r?\n> UNIT", but

\r?\n> referred to in the description as "CYCLO unit". The illustration

\r?\n> is of the

\r?\n> large flange BW hub.

\r?\n>

\r?\n> A couple of general points - the teeth on the sprockets supplied

\r?\n> for the BW

\r?\n> hubs were flat-topped. The1939 Brown Brothers catalogue states

\r?\n> that

\r?\n> standard hub sprockets (I assume that this means fixed sprockets)

\r?\n> will fit,

\r?\n> but will NOT work satisfactorily with derailleur gears. This seems

\r?\n> strange,

\r?\n> because Cyclo and Trivelox were supplying three speed blocks with

\r?\n> pointed

\r?\n> teeth, like those of a fixed sprocket, at that time, and in my

\r?\n> experience,

\r?\n> they work fine. I haven't yet tried a BW Unit hub with fixed

\r?\n> sprockets, but

\r?\n> I guess maybe Mick or Doug have? I suspect that this was a

\r?\n> marketing ploy

\r?\n> on the part of BW.

\r?\n>

\r?\n> Both the BW and Cyclo unit hubs were listed in the 1952 Brown

\r?\n> Brothers

\r?\n> catalogue, although the BW illustration is of the small flange hub,

\r?\n> and the

\r?\n> Cyclo illustration is of the large flange BW! Neither appears in

\r?\n> the 1956

\r?\n> edition. The BW hub is also listed in the 1952 Hobday Bros

\r?\n> Catalogue (with

\r?\n> the large flange hub illustrated) but it doesn't appear in the 1954

\r?\n> edition.

\r?\n>

\r?\n> Neil Foddering

\r?\n> Weymouth, England