Re: [CR]Heresy? Adding braze-ons to a "classic" frame

(Example: Racing:Jean Robic)

From: <travis.harry@gmail.com>
Date: Mon, 04 Aug 2008 18:41:01 -0300
To: <classicrendezvous@bikelist.org>
In-Reply-To: <B91151B7-8453-42EF-B163-4AAED26177F7@earthlink.net>
Subject: Re: [CR]Heresy? Adding braze-ons to a "classic" frame

I'd follow up to ask specifically about the plastic under-BB cable guides. Is there reason to fear the structural integrity of the shell would be violated by drilling the single hole required to secure such a guide? I understand proscriptions,for engineering reasons from adding cable guides and bottle cage anchors to frame tubes.

Harry Travis Washington, DC USA

said Harry Travis, stirred by:
       Jon Spangler <hudsonspangler@earthlink.net>'s message of:
       Monday 04 Aug 08 at 02:40 PM,
       On: [CR]Heresy? Adding braze-ons to a "classic" frame
       [echoed below, in part<=1]
                        -oOo-
>Dear CR folks,
>As I consider purchasing and building up a classic bike--probably a
>mid-1970s Allegro--an ethical--one might even say "theological"--
>question comes to mind, as the Allegros came with minimal braze-ons
>in the "clean" style of the times.
>In order to equip and ride this bike on a regular basis, I would want
>to add braze-on BB cable guides, Campi shift-lever bosses, bottle
>cage mounts, and perhaps TT cable guides. (The frames I'm looking at
>will need painting in any case, as far as I can tell from the
>pictures, but have not been ridden much, if at all.)
>Just how "heretical" would this be, and are there any other options
>besides using all-clamp-on components, which I found dysfunctional
>"back in the day." Are there any less-invasive options, such as using
>the plastic under-BB cable guides? HPT -- ----------------------------------------------------------- travis.dot.harry.trying.gmail.com DemostiX