[CR] The highly subjective nature of excellence in old machinery, part 4

(Example: Events:Cirque du Cyclisme:2002)

Date: Mon, 3 Aug 2009 09:51:23 -0700
From: <euromeccanicany@yahoo.com>
To: classic rendezvous <classicrendezvous@bikelist.org>
Subject: [CR] The highly subjective nature of excellence in old machinery, part 4


Back to bikes. Like you, I've owned and ridden many bikes. I have my favorites. When I got a Pogliaghi track bike a few weeks ago, I tidied it up, put on wheels from my beloved 1950s Frejus and took it out. It is 1cm larger than the Frejus, but I still had no trouble getting comfortable on it. Now if you read about these two bikes on line, you will find the Frejus is given credit for being a nice bike , but nothing special is called out other than their beauty ("mediocre workmanship",-Sheldon Brown). Sante Pogliaghi, by contrast, is often grouped with Cino Cinelli and Faliero Masi and spoken of with the reverence accorded minor deities. After riding the Pog, I respect it. The Frejus, by contrast, makes me want to write love poetry. It makes me tremble. I love my wife, but oh you bike! It feels like a part of me when I ride. The Pogliaghi is an excellent bicycle. It feels good to ride. As I said, I respect it. Others may love it: not me. This is why "the best" doesn't apply to saxes, canoes, cars or bicycles. Or husbands and wives. There is the element of love, composed of conscious and subconscious associations with pleasant things, unmeasurable sensations and indescribable qualities, which informs our relationship with important people and things. Fine bikes, cars, saxes, e.g. are built and appreciated by passionate people, far more than microwaves and cell phones. Michael Shiffer EuroMeccanica, Inc. 114 Pearl Street Mount Vernon, NY 10550 (914) 668-1300 euromeccanicany.com